Nuts and bolts
Microsoft outages, AI lawsuits, and all the latest Canadian legal news

What do you do when opposing counsel turns every email into a fight?
On November 30, we’re putting lawyers on the clock to share their best approaches to difficult people. Each speaker gets five minutes to explain a technique they’ve used, what they said or did, and how it worked out. You’ll help choose the winner by voting for the idea you’re most likely to try yourself.
Join us online on Monday, November 30. Registration is free, and the event is approved for CPD credit in Ontario and BC.
Register for “Dealing with people who drive you nuts.”
— Dylan Gibbs
TODAY’S DOCKET |
Microsoft’s day off
Self-updating file lists
Canadian publishers v. OpenAI
Non-consensual scans?
Maternity leave as working notice
MAKING HEADLINES

💻 If last week’s Microsoft outage kept you out of your inbox, you might soon have company in a class action. A Markham business has launched a proposed Canada-wide lawsuit, saying it lost roughly a day’s access to client emails, meetings and files. The claim accuses Microsoft of failing to deliver its promised reliability and seeks compensation for the resulting losses.
🤖 Four nonprofits want to freeze AI development. Their California lawsuit alleges that companies like OpenAI and Anthropic keep forging ahead with new models despite knowing the latest advancements could enable bioweapons and catastrophic cyberattacks.
💊 Ontario won’t be restricting safer supply just yet. A Toronto advocacy group asked the court to block new prescribing rules that were set to take effect this week, including a ban on take-home doses. Ontario’s medical regulator paused enforcement while it responds to the injunction motion.
🎓 Ontario wants to tighten the rules for private career colleges after provincial student grants to the sector nearly doubled to about $1 billion in a year. The proposals would limit student-aid funding, increase penalties and make colleges answer for their agents’ conduct. Colleges would also have to stop sharing campuses with unrelated businesses like immigration firms.
⏱️ Baker McKenzie is dropping the billable hour as the firm's default pricing model. For years, litigators have insisted that complex cases are too unpredictable to price any other way. Now, empowered by the latest AI advancements, one of the world’s biggest law firms is telling its lawyers to take a closer look at value-based fees. Is this the beginning of the end for hourly billing, or just another chapter in an age-old story?
🔒 Ontario wants to make it easier to get intimate images off the internet. The province tabled legislation that gives victims an expedited court process for takedown requests, and the right to sue anyone who makes, shares, or threatens to share an intimate image without consent. The protections would cover AI-generated deepfakes too.
📱 WhatsApp and Signal could disappear from Canada if Parliament passes its lawful-access bill without further changes. The companies behind the apps warned senators that the proposed surveillance requirements would compromise the security of private messages — a compromise the companies aren't willing to make.
IN FOCUS
Who’s updating your file list?

When I was practicing law, my master file list was the bane of my existence.
In theory, it was useful. It gave me a place to keep track of all the files on my plate, including all the ones that weren't currently on fire.
But when you're in the thick of it, actively fighting fires, who has time to update a file list? Dusting off Excel to tell a clunky spreadsheet what I’d done, and the expected next step? Yeah, right.
Despite the best intentions of an ambitious associate, my master file list soon became a decrepit artifact — mostly untouched, and less useful every time I delayed the administrative burden of keeping it current.
A lawyer in our community for entrepreneurial Canadian lawyers has been building something better with Claude Cowork. The goal: a system that updates itself as he works, flags what needs attention, and doesn't require spending just as much time on admin as actual work.
This lawyer got into building with AI through the free AI Executive Assistant setup we give to Inn Laws members. Now he’s creating tools for his practice like an AI savant.
His file tickler was close to what he wanted, but he needed help getting his AI assistant to focus on the right priorities. So he brought a demo with fictional files to one of our peer groups: small, moderated groups where we match lawyers working through similar challenges.
He left with the group's advice on specific improvements that could make the tool better: a more intuitive design, more detail about the AI's triage decisions, and a learning loop that saves his corrections so the AI gets better each day.
They say you're the average of the five people you spend the most time with. If I were still practicing, I’d want to surround myself with lawyers doing things like this. Folks experimenting with AI, comparing what works, and making practicing law more enjoyable.
Every week, I see Inn Laws members finding ways to automate things I used to hate doing in practice. If you want to spend more time with AI-pilled lawyers, apply to join us.
P.S. What’s one thing in your practice you wish you didn’t have to keep doing manually? Hit reply. I’m curious.
FROM THE COURTS

Unlawful COVID restrictions? No problem.
Ingram v. Alberta, 2026 ABCA 366
Alberta business owners won the battle against Alberta’s COVID restrictions but ultimately lost the war. In 2023, the Court of King’s Bench ruled that Alberta's Cabinet unlawfully made pandemic decisions that ought to have been made by the province's chief medical officer. The plaintiffs, who lost revenue because of restrictions put in place through that decision-making process, wanted compensation. Instead, they came face-to-face with a causation problem — the evidence suggested that the chief medical officer may have been more strict with businesses — not less.
If anything, the proposed representative plaintiffs may have benefitted from [the less restrictive orders] made by Cabinet...
Stay where you are, Canadian publishers
Toronto Star Newspapers v. OpenAI, 2026 ONCA 814
Canadian news publishers are in the long line of plaintiffs suing OpenAI for copyright infringement. But can they sue at home — or must they fly south to the land of the tech behemoths? According to the Ontario Court of Appeal, OpenAI's Ontario-based activities, including sales, contracts, and advertising, formed enough of a connection to the province to let the publishers sue locally:
[T]he [OpenAI companies] either made contractual arrangements in Ontario, advertised to users including in Ontario, or licensed their tools to customers either directly or through third parties. …
[T]here was a good arguable case that [the OpenAI companies] carried on business in Ontario for the context of assumed jurisdiction, even without a physical presence.
Want support? Consider moving to Ontario
Bratusa v. Doersam, 2026 ONCA 792
Can a new Ontario resident claim support from her late partner’s estate? The Court of Appeal said yes to a woman who moved here with her daughter after her partner died in Costa Rica. The deceased's will left his family nothing. Despite the relationship taking place in Costa Rica, the court focused on where the mother and daughter currently need support:
The needs arise and are ongoing in the jurisdiction where the claimants are located at the time the claim is made.
BY THE NUMBERS

$400,000: The cost to settle a class action over allegedly non-consensual MRI scans. Members of Pictou Landing First Nation agreed to scans for one research project, but say the doctors took extra scans of their livers for a separate study without telling them. The Nova Scotia Supreme Court approved the settlement last week.
3: The minimum number of attempts Canada will need to draft environmental assessment legislation that complies with the Constitution. The federal government rewrote the law after the SCC rejected much of it in 2023, but the Alberta Court of Appeal says the revised version still oversteps federal powers. The government decided to take another crack at the drafting rather than attempting to appeal.
651: The number of properties two First Nations want to own in Ontario. The Nations sued the federal and provincial governments over treaty breaches, and they want a proprietary remedy beyond just compensation. The Crown asked the Court to dismiss the proprietary claim before trial, but the motion judge left it alone.
THINGS NOT TO DO 😤
Don’t turn maternity leave into a deadline to find another job.
An Alberta law firm told an associate on maternity leave that she had no long-term future there and suggested she use the months left on leave to find another job. The firm also asked its HR manager how long it legally had to keep the lawyer after she returned.
Alberta’s human rights tribunal found discrimination and awarded the lawyer $76,370 in compensation, including $45,000 in lost income for a period that overlapped with her maternity leave:
I have considered the unusual fact that a significant portion of [the compensable wage loss] overlapped with maternity leave, during which [the lawyer] would not ordinarily have received her salary.
The [law firm] cannot, however, obtain the benefit of treating [the lawyer's] protected leave as a period of unpaid working notice.
![]() Dylan Gibbs | That’s all for today. Govern yourself accordingly. If someone sent you this email, subscribe here. Comments? Hit reply. |

Reply